Infrastructure Development and Marginalisation: Perceptions Negotiated through Mass Media Coverage - A Study of Vizhinjam International Seaport Project, Kerala, India

Abstract

A quarter century experience of a paradigm shift to neo-liberal economic policies and the subsequent development agenda were instrumental in creating tangible growth as well as new forms of marginalisation and displacement in India. This dichotomy led to many studies which examined the nature of public responses to mass media coverage of various components pertaining to this larger issue.  This study has focused on the Vizhinjam International Seaport Project of Kerala (a south Indian State) and the perceptions of the fishing community living there towards this project as negotiated through the mass media coverage. Consequently the media-driven perceptions among the fishing community and their real view about these issues or factors were analysed separately through a field study. It was observed that their perceptions about this massive infrastructural project were not primarily conditioned by the mass media coverage. It was revealed that, although media coverage was strident in portraying the project as an 'imperative' for development, it was not helpful in allaying the fears of displacement and marginalisation among the fisherfolk. Despite being exposed to the chances of embracing 'modern lifestyles' by migrating to jobs other than in the fishing sector, the community was not persuaded to do so. Thus the study points towards the critical necessity of engaging in a truly participatory communication with the primary stakeholders right from the formative stages of development programmes and projects.

Keywords

Infrastructure development, Displacement, Marginalisation, Mass Media, perceptions, CAD

References

1. Adiga, Shreenidhi and Poornananda, D.S. (2014). 'Media and the movement against Mangalore Special Economic Zone'. Mass Communicator, October-December Issue.
2. Akoija, Indira (2012). 'No focus on development issues'. The Hoot. Retrieved from www.thehoot.org
3. Aneesh, T.V. , Patil, R.R. (2015). 'Development and displacement in Kerala: An experience of Cochin International Airport Limited'. European Scientific Journal. June/ Special edition.
4. Datta, Amrita, (2009). 'Public private partnerships in India: A case for reform?'. Economic and Political Weekly. August 15, Vol. XLIV. No.33
5. Feldman, Lauren. (2011). The effects of Journalist opinionation on learning from news. Journal of Communication, 61. 1180-1200
6. Government of Kerala. (2015). A livelihood Impact Assessment Report. Retrieved from http://www.vizhinjamport.in/download/LIACReportSept2015-F.pdf
7. http://www.thehoot.org/research/books/no-focus-on-development-issues-6159; 8th August 2012.
8. International Finance Corporation. (2010). Strategic options report. Retrieved from www.vizhinjamport.in/downloads/Kerala_Port_SOR_FINAL.pdf
9. Jan, Servaes. (1986). Communication and development paradigms: An overview. Media Asia. Vol. 13. No.3. 128-136
10. Madhav, R. (2008). “Tirupur water Supply and Sanitation Project: An Impediment To Sustainable Water Management?”, Working Paper, International Environment and Law Research Centre, http://www.ielrc.org/content/w0801.pdf
11. Manyozo, Linje. (2012). Media, Communication and Development - Three Approaches. New Delhi: Sage.
12. Melkote, R. Srinivas and Steeves, H. Leslie (2015). Communication for Development in the third world. Theory and practice of empowerment. New Delhi: Sage.
13. Mody, Bella. (1991). Designing messages for development communication- An audience participation based approach. Delhi: Sage.
14. Narula, Uma (2014). Handbook of Communication- Models, Perspectives, Strategies. New Delhi: Atlantic.
15. Nora C.Quebral (1986). Is it Government Communication or People Communication? Will the real development Communication Please Stand Up? Media Asia. Vol 13 No 2.
16. Parayil, Govindan. (2000). 'Introduction: Is Kerala a 'model'? In Parayil, Govindan.(Ed.), Kerala: 'The Development Experience - Reflections on sustainability and replicability'. (p10). London: Zed Books.
17. Rukmani, Lali Yadav., Sumitra, Yadav( 2009). ' Dissemination of development information in print and electronic media'. Journal of Mobilization and Sustainable Development, Vol 4, Issue 1, June
18. Sinha, Dipankar. (2013). Development Communication- Contexts for the twenty- first century. New Delhi: Orient BlackSwan.
19. State Planning Board, Kerala. (2015). Economic review 2015. Retrieved from www.spb.kerala.gov.in